POLITICS OF ANTAGONISM VERSUS POLITICS OF ALTERNATIVE VIEWS
POLITICS OF ANTAGONISM VERSUS POLITICS OF ALTERNATIVE VIEWS
By Joseph Ibekwe
Democracy is not strengthened by silencing opposing voices, discrediting dissenting opinions or treating every alternative perspective as an act of hostility. Rather, democracy is deepened when opposing views are given the opportunity to be heard, examined, debated and, where necessary, accommodated.
One of the greatest weaknesses of democratic politics is the tendency to confuse political disagreement with political antagonism. The fact that someone disagrees with your position does not necessarily make that person your enemy. Neither does the presentation of an alternative political perspective amount to an attempt to undermine your leadership or political ambition.
Politics of antagonism seeks to defeat, discredit and silence. It thrives on hostility, suspicion, personal attacks and the deliberate creation of divisions. Its ultimate objective is often not to advance better ideas but to ensure that opposing voices have no meaningful place in the political conversation.
Politics of alternative views, on the other hand, recognises that no individual, political party or governing institution possesses a monopoly of wisdom. It appreciates that different experiences, perspectives and ideas can contribute to better decisions, stronger institutions and more responsive governance.
Indeed, the strength of democracy is not measured by how effectively those in power suppress opposition, but by how confidently they accommodate dissent.
A government that is genuinely confident in its ideas should not be afraid of criticism. A political leader who understands democratic responsibility should be willing to listen, even when the views expressed are uncomfortable. And an opposition that understands its democratic responsibility should recognise that its role extends beyond opposing those in power to offering credible alternatives for national development.
We must therefore move away from a political culture in which disagreement is interpreted as disloyalty, criticism as hostility and
alternative opinions as threats.
Democracy is a marketplace of ideas, not a battlefield of egos. Its greatest victories are not achieved when one side silences the other, but when competing perspectives produce better choices for society.
Unfortunately, many of those in today’s political space do not understand the principle of tolerance nor do they have the humility to listen to alternative views. Instead, Whatever ideas that do not align with theirs counts for nothing.
The society loses when single narratives dominate the public space. There is no political candidate or political party that has all the answers to all the problems in the polity. Countering others without resorting to personal attacks or castigating genuine ideas, just because they are not coming from your political camp is the hallmark of immature political actors.
From my experience, I have come to the conclusion that the greatest problem of our democracy is the elite – they are responsible for creating and promoting divicive narratives and instigating the ignorance masses to undermine democratic processes through their stereotypic narratives that does not recognize the importance of alternative views.
The future of democracy depends not on eliminating opposing voices, but on developing the maturity and institutional capacity to listen to them.
That is the difference between politics that merely seeks power and politics that advances society.
Democracy is not deepened by shooting down opposition voices, but by listening to alternative voices.
Joseph Chinenyeze Ibekwe is a public leadership professional and President,
African Institute of Public Leadership -AIPL
He writes from Abuja – Nigeria
